Curious Patents
Episode 15 · US Patent 1,150,523 (filed 1911, granted 1915) · US Patent 745,157 (1903)

The Electric Self-Starter

In 1903 the United States granted a patent for a motor that starts a car's engine, then turns into a dynamo and charges the battery. It was not Charles Kettering's: he filed his eight years later, and his is the one in the history books. Drive Kettering's starting device from its clutch pedal and run Coleman's 1903 gears beside it, both rebuilt from the patents' drawings; read the patents, and see every source.

Watch the episode

Curious Patents, Episode 15, The Electric Self-Starter: the first sheets of Coleman's and Kettering's patents beside our reconstruction of Kettering's starting device
On YouTube from 13 November

Two patents, eight years apart

Clyde J. Coleman, of New York, filed his patent in February 1901, and it was granted on 24 November 1903 (US 745,157, assigned to the Rockaway Automobile Company, of New Jersey). It describes a motor that starts a car's engine, then is driven by the engine as a dynamo and charges the battery (pp. 1-2).

Charles F. Kettering, of Dayton, Ohio, filed his "Engine-starting device" on 15 June 1911. It was granted on 17 August 1915, to his company, the Dayton Engineering Laboratories Co. (US 1,150,523). So what did Kettering patent that was not already on the page? In short: a clutch pedal with two jobs, a magnet that decides when it has them, and a battery rewired in the middle of a start (claims 6, 8, 19-23). The model further down lets you work all three.

What the crank did

Magazine paragraph headed In Cranking the Motor
"In Cranking the Motor". The Automobile (New York), 14 March 1912, p. 721.

Before the self-starter, a gasoline engine was started by hand, with a crank at the front of the car. The danger was the backfire. If the spark came too early, the engine could kick back and throw the crank the wrong way, against the hand that held it (The Automobile, 14 March 1912, p. 721: "back-kicks when cranking"; "The spark should be retarded").

The trade weekly warned against pushing down on the crank: "A broken arm or shoulder or perhaps both are apt to result from this practice in case of a backfire." And it put a number on it: "In this country there are about 500 of these accidents a year according to figures furnished by insurance companies. There must be far more than this", it went on, counting the drivers who had no insurance (p. 721).

The drawing starts when you scroll to it
Swipe sideways across the drawing to see all of it.
Letter to the editor headed Need of Safety Cranks
"Need of Safety Cranks", a letter from V. L. Gass, Boston. The Automobile, 14 December 1911, p. 1056.

Readers had written in already. A letter printed in December 1911 began: "Just the other day I read in the paper of another broken arm as the result of trying to start a motor with the old-fashioned starting crank" (V. L. Gass, Boston, in The Automobile, 14 December 1911, p. 1056).

Those are reported accidents, not deaths. The advice was to retard the spark first, and to crank with the left hand, where a kick "is apt to have the least possible chance to do damage" (The Automobile, 1912, p. 721). An electric motor at the flywheel would take the hand off the crank altogether.

The story usually told

Portrait of an old man with a white beard and moustache
Henry M. Leland. The World's Work, vol. 41 (1921), p. 565.

The story usually told is that a friend of Henry Leland, the head of Cadillac, was killed by a crank on a Detroit bridge, and that Leland then asked Kettering to get rid of the crank. It has several versions: in GM's The Turning Wheel (1934, which names no one), in T. A. Boyd's Kettering biography (1957) and in the Lelands' biography (1966), as the Cartercar history site, cartercar.org, lists them. The earliest account we know of that names the man, Byron Carter, is Boyd's of 1957 (as cartercar.org lists it; we have not seen the book).

Carter's own death was reported in the Detroit Times on 6 April 1908: "BYRON J. CARTER IS DEAD FROM PNEUMONIA". "Mr. Carter had been ill but a week."

A year earlier, a report from Detroit told of a different Carter, H. O. Carter, of the Carter Motor Car Corporation, "struck in the face by a crank he was using to start a Cadillac car on the Belle Isle river drive". It ended: "It is expected, however, he will recover." (The Washington Times, 26 April 1907, p. 3.)

Neither report names Leland, Kettering or a starter. We found no account from the time that ties either man to the starter.

Coleman, 1903

Patent sheet with a plan of the gearing, a gear diagram and a wiring diagram
US 745,157, sheet 2: Fig. 2, the plan; Fig. 3, the gearing; Fig. 4, the circuit.

Coleman called his patent "Means for operating motor-vehicles", and its first idea is the one we call the self-starter. An electric "motor-dynamo" is geared to the engine. Run from a storage battery, it turns the engine over; once the engine runs, the engine drives it back, and it charges the battery (US 745,157, pp. 1-2).

The trick is two pairs of gears, each with its own one-way clutch: steel balls that wedge in one direction and roll free in the other (Fig. 3). As a motor, it drives the engine through a small gear on a large one, pinion 9 on gear 11, slowly, "with considerable advantage of leverage" (p. 2). When the engine fires and outruns it, that clutch lets go, and the second pair takes over: friction gears 14 and 10, "both of the same diameter", so now the engine turns the dynamo at its own speed.

The model starts when you scroll to it
Swipe sideways across the drawing to see all of it.
stillmotor-dynamo, shaft 15
stoppedengine, shaft 6

From the patent (Fig. 3; pp. 1-2): pinion 9 on the motor-dynamo's shaft 15, always in mesh with gear 11, which is loose on engine shaft 6 and drives it through ratchet 12 and gripping balls 13; friction gear 14, keyed to shaft 6, always against friction gear 10, which is loose on shaft 15 and drives it through ratchet 16 and balls 17; 14 and 10 "both of the same diameter". Balls that are holding are drawn red. Ours: the 1 to 4 of pinion 9 and gear 11 (the drawing shows 11 about four times the size of 9), the number of balls, the speeds, the moment the engine fires (2.7 seconds after the motor starts), and the motor stopping as it fires, as the episode draws it. In the patent it is the lever's further movement that cuts the motor (below). Checked by the episode's test: as a motor it turns four times for each turn of the engine, as a dynamo once; the two ball clutches never hold at once, which would lock the gears.

One lever by the seat runs the start. Its first movement switches on the motor, opens the fuel and closes the spark circuit, while the wheels stay disconnected. Pushed further, it cuts off the motor and connects the engine to the wheels. So the engine is started, in Coleman's words, "while relieved of its load" (pp. 1, 3). A governor closes the charging circuit only when the engine reaches its normal speed, so the battery is not overcharged (pp. 2-3).

The diagram starts when you scroll to it
Swipe sideways across the drawing to see all of it.
at restpushed all the way
at restlever 24
openmotor circuit
shutsupply valve 20
opensparking circuit
freethe wheels

From the specification (p. 3) and claims 2 and 14-16: the first movement of lever 24 closes the motor circuit, opens supply valve 20 and closes the sparking circuit while friction wheel 25 sits in the recess of disk 23, so the wheels are not driven; further movement breaks the motor circuit and moves friction-gear 25 out across the disk's face, "farther away from the axis", so the engine drives the wheels, faster the further it goes; governor 53 closes the charging circuit at the engine's normal speed. Ours: the positions along the lever's travel at which each thing switches.

So a motor that starts the engine and then charges the battery, and a start with the wheels disconnected, were in a patent of 1903. One thing his design never needs: his gears are always in mesh, and the balls choose which pair does the driving. We found no record that Coleman's design was built or sold.

Kettering, Leland and Delco

Photograph of a man in a suit and glasses, speaking
Charles F. Kettering in 1936, long after the starter. Harris & Ewing, Library of Congress.

Charles Kettering was an engineer at the National Cash Register Company, in Dayton, Ohio. In 1909 he and Edward Deeds set up the Dayton Engineering Laboratories Company, which came to be called Delco (according to Mark Strecker's history of the starter and to Delco's own company history; the company's name is in the patent's heading).

Its first big customer was Cadillac, for ignition. In October 1911, Motor Age wrote that Delco ignition had "been in successful use on the Cadillac cars for the past two years" (5 October 1911, p. 34). Cadillac was run by Henry Leland, a machinist known for precision (as Strecker's page puts it, quoting earlier histories).

Delco's own history, unsigned and undated, has Leland telling Kettering: "If you can provide an electric starter, I will put it on my 1912 car." Work on the starter began in 1910, according to that history, in the barn behind Deeds's house in Dayton, where Kettering had worked since 1908 ("Deeds Barn and the Self Starter").

Kettering filed for a whole system, starting, lighting and ignition together, in April 1911 (US 1,171,055), and for the starting device itself in June (US 1,150,523).

Magazine page headed Delco Starting, Lighting and Ignition, with a wiring diagram
"Delco Starting, Lighting and Ignition": "in successful use on the Cadillac cars for the past two years". Motor Age (Chicago), 5 October 1911, p. 34.

Kettering's patent

The starting patent was granted in August 1915, for an "Engine-starting device". Kettering is the inventor; his company in Dayton owns it. Its first drawing is a car's chassis from above, and the text names the car: "the 'Cadillac' which is a well known automobile, on the market at the present time" (US 1,150,523, p. 3).

Two parts matter most. The flywheel, the heavy wheel at the back of the engine, has teeth round its rim; and beside the engine sits one electric machine, a "motor-generator", that both starts and charges (pp. 2-3, Fig. 1). The other sheets show a magnet on the clutch shaft, the gears that reach the flywheel, and the wiring.

On its first page, the patent says what it is about: a foot pedal that couples the starter to the engine, "but this foot pedal is in itself, normally disconnected". It is the ordinary clutch pedal. The same push that starts the engine frees it from the wheels, so its load "will be materially reduced", and the car cannot move off by itself: "a safety device, which prevents the inadvertent or accidental starting of the car" (p. 1).

"... so constructed that the forward movement of the clutch pedal will simultaneously disengage the clutch from the engine and couple up the engine and the starting device."

Claim 6 of US 1,150,523.

How it works: drive it yourself

Here is the starting device, rebuilt from the patent's drawings: the mechanism on the left, drawn unfolded into one plane, and the wiring on the right, simplified from Fig. 8. Both run on one clock. Start with the pedal alone; then hold the button and press the pedal, steadily. The line under the controls says what is happening, and the patent's own account follows below the model.

The model starts when you scroll to it
Swipe sideways across the drawing: the mechanism is on the left, the wiring on the right.
Show:
Push button 67:
upall the way down
0%pedal 32 pressed
on the flywheelclutch 30
offlatch 40
outpinion 71
CHARGEcontroller 82
6 Vfour units side by side
stillmotor-generator 33
stoppedengine
opencut-out

From the patent (Figs. 1-8; pp. 1-13): clutch pedal 32 on clutch shaft 31, transmission clutch 30 against flywheel 28 with its teeth 29; arm 43 keyed to the shaft; bracket 34 loose on it, with magnet 37 and latch 40 (hook 42), the magnet's coil 69 fed through push button 67; link 48, levers 49 and 53 on shaft 50, the flexible connection with spring 76, fork 72 and the sleeve with pinions 71 and 73; motor pinion 74 on motor-generator 33; link 54, plunger 55 with spring 58, pawl 57 and controller handle 82; the battery of four units of three cells, side by side to charge and end to end to start, "practically 24 volts" (p. 7); roller clutch 232 to shaft 27 (Figs. 1a, 1b); the cut-out (113-122). Ours: the drawing unfolded into one plane (the patent's parts sit at different depths), the layout, every size, the tooth counts (20 to 1 overall, the figure Motor Age gives for the 1912 Cadillac; the patent gives no ratio), the speeds and timing (slowed), the turns before the engine fires, the voltages at which the cut-out closes and opens, and the wiring as a block diagram. In our model a fast push on the pedal can switch to START before the pinion is in; the patent relies on the slow turn and the pedal's travel to keep the order. Not shown, as the patent leaves them to other applications: a device against throwing the gears in while the engine runs, and a limit on the motor's speed (claims 9-10), so here the pedal does nothing more once the engine has fired. Checked by the episode's test, run again on this page's copy: 54 checks, all pass: the parts fit; the order of events is the patent's; no tooth ever passes through a tooth; the battery is six volts side by side and twenty-four end to end and never shorted; planted faults (no slow turn, no flexible link, a switch that makes before it breaks, a pawl knocked clear too early) are caught.

What happens, in the patent's order

At rest, the pedal works the clutch, and nothing else. Press it, and the arm on the clutch shaft rocks past the magnet, which rides loose on the same shaft ("normally loosely mounted on the clutch shaft", p. 13). Nothing follows it.

To start, the driver holds down a push button. A small current, about six volts, flows through the magnet's coil and on through the motor. The magnet pulls its latch in, and the hook catches the arm: now the magnet and its bracket are locked to the pedal (Figs. 2-3, p. 5). The same current turns the motor slowly, with little force: it "rotates slowly, and develops a comparatively low torque" (p. 5). That slow turn has a job to do.

Now the pedal goes down. The clutch leaves the flywheel, so the wheels are free, and the latched bracket pulls a train of levers that slides a pinion toward the flywheel's teeth (pp. 5-6; claim 6). If a tooth meets a tooth, end to end, the pinion cannot go in. A spring in the linkage gives, so nothing breaks; the slow turn brings a gap round, and the pinion slides home (p. 5; claims 11, 16).

Only then does the switch move. A plunger, pushed by the same levers, has been squeezing a spring; now it knocks a pawl clear, and the spring snaps the switch over, fast. The shift "occurs so quickly that the danger of arcing ... is reduced to a minimum" (p. 6; claim 21). The four units of three cells, side by side, gave six volts; the switch puts them end to end, "practically 24 volts", into the motor (pp. 7, 10, 12). Four times the voltage, and the motor cranks the engine round (p. 6).

When the engine fires, the driver lets the pedal up. A spring pulls the pinion out, the plunger pushes the switch back, and the batteries return to six volts, side by side. Let go of the button, and the latch drops; the clutch meets the flywheel again, and the car is ready to drive (pp. 12-13).

The motor now runs as a generator, driven by the engine through a roller clutch, which slipped while the motor was cranking and now locks (pp. 6-7, Figs. 1a, 1b). When its voltage passes the battery's, a relay closes, and the batteries charge, all four together, at about six volts; if the engine slows and the generator's voltage falls, the relay opens again, so the batteries never drive it backwards (pp. 8-9).

The patent gives no sizes, speeds or gear ratios. The ones in our model are ours.

The 1912 Cadillac

Photograph of a 1912 open touring car
"The 1912 Cadillac fore-door touring car design". Motor Age, 5 October 1911, p. 30.

In October 1911, Motor Age described the Cadillac for 1912, with "an automatic electric starting device" and electric lights (5 October 1911, p. 30). To start it, the driver "simply retards the spark lever and pushes forward on the clutch pedal" (p. 34).

That is the patent's pedal, with two differences. There was no push button: the switch that turned the motor slowly closed when the spark lever was pulled all the way to retard (p. 34). And the gearing to the flywheel had "a double gear reduction of 20 to 1" (p. 35); the patent gives no ratio. The model above shows the Cadillac's version too: choose "The 1912 Cadillac" over the controls.

The battery was the patent's: twelve cells in four groups, in series to start at twenty-four volts, and in parallel for charging and the lights (p. 35). Retarding the spark was also the first rule of cranking by hand (The Automobile, 1912, p. 721). On the Cadillac, the same move began the start.

Motor Age said the battery could turn the engine over for "about 20 minutes", though it "seldom requires more than a second or so" to start (p. 34). That is the magazine's description, before the cars reached buyers, not a test we can check.

What Kettering added: the two patents side by side

Read from the claims and the specifications only.

US 745,157 (Coleman, filed 1901, granted 1903) and US 1,150,523 (Kettering, filed 1911, granted 1915), claims and specifications. Nothing in either text says Kettering knew of Coleman.
Coleman, 745,157Kettering, 1,150,523
A motor that starts the engine, then is driven as a dynamo to charge a batteryYes, a "motor-dynamo" (claims 3-13, 17-24)Yes, a "motor-generator"; the charging claims are left to the divisional application (p. 1)
Engine started with the wheels disconnectedYes, by the first movement of a hand lever ("while relieved of its load", p. 1; claim 2)Yes, by the clutch pedal ("the load of the engine will be materially reduced", p. 1; claims 6, 22, 23)
One-way (ball or roller) clutchYes, two: on the starting gear (12, 13) and the charging gear (16, 17)Yes, one: on the generator drive (232, Figs. 1a, 1b); not claimed
Gears between motor and engineAlways in mesh; the clutches choose the pathNormally disconnected: a pinion moved into the flywheel's teeth to start and pulled out after (claims 14-17, 29-34)
Lining the teeth upNot needed (always meshed)A slow, low-torque turn before meshing, "a movement of registration" (claims 12-21, 26-28, 32-34)
A yielding link if the teeth meet end onNoYes, flexible means (claim 11)
ControlA hand lever, switching by its own latches c, dThe ordinary clutch pedal, made to work the starter only while a magnet latch is energised from a push button (claims 1-8, 23, 35-37)
BatteryOne battery, 40Regrouped: units in parallel (about 6 volts) to charge, in series (24 volts) to start, switched by a spring-snapped controller only after the gears mesh (claims 19-24)
Charging switchCentrifugal governor 53 on the motor shaftCut-out relay (Fig. 8, 113-122)

So Coleman had the starter-dynamo, the start with the wheels disconnected, and one-way clutches. Kettering's claims are the coupling (a pinion meshed on demand, lined up by a slow turn, with a yielding link), the pedal with its magnet latch, and the battery switched from parallel to series after the mesh.

Two more patents

The starting patent sends some of its subject elsewhere. Parts of it, the text says, are also shown in Kettering's application of April 1911, and its charging features are claimed in a divisional application (US 1,150,523, p. 1).

The April application was granted in February 1916, as an "Engine starting, lighting, and ignition system": one battery and one machine, for starting, the lights and the ignition (US 1,171,055, filed 17 April 1911, granted 8 February 1916). The divisional was filed in March 1915 and granted in June 1917 (US 1,231,266, filed 5 March 1915, granted 26 June 1917). So the patents came out years after the cars: the first in 1915, the last in 1917.

From the patents' first pages.
PatentTitleFiledGranted
US 1,171,055Engine starting, lighting, and ignition system17 April 19118 February 1916
US 1,150,523Engine-starting device15 June 191117 August 1915
US 1,231,266Engine-starting device (divisional)5 March 191526 June 1917

Who could drive

According to a later account, other makers soon took up Delco starters, and Ford offered an electric starter on the Model T in 1919 (Mac's Motor City Garage, "Cadillac's Great Leap Forward", 2024; the page gives no sources for this).

The Automobile, on the same page that counted the accidents, saw another reason it mattered. "It is hardly to be wondered at", it wrote, "that the automobile world is studying the self-starter question very carefully, if only for the safety part of the idea."

"The question of having the gasoline motor car so arranged that it can be safely operated by a woman hinges directly on the subject of self-starters, for it is only the difficulty of starting the motor which prevents them from driving more than they do."

The Automobile, 14 March 1912, p. 721.

That is a trade paper's opinion, in 1912. We found no figures for who bought the starter, or for who drove because of it.

Then and now

A starter today does the same jobs with different parts. A solenoid, an electromagnet, pushes the pinion into the flywheel's teeth and closes the heavy contacts to the motor. A one-way clutch on the pinion lets the engine run free once it fires, and a spring pulls the pinion back when the key or button is let go (Wikipedia, "Starter (engine)").

The drawing starts when you scroll to it
Swipe sideways across the drawing to see all of it.

In Kettering's design, the pedal and its latch did the solenoid's pushing, the spring-loaded switch did its switching, and a spring pulled the pinion back. His one roller clutch is on the generator (US 1,150,523). Most cars start on twelve volts today (Wikipedia); Kettering's motor cranked on twenty-four (p. 12).

Kettering's parts from US 1,150,523; today's from Wikipedia, "Starter (engine)".
The jobKettering, 1911A starter today
Push the pinion into the flywheel's teethClutch pedal 32, through magnet latch 40 and the leversThe solenoid
Close the heavy contacts to the motorController 82, snapped over by spring 58The solenoid
Let the engine run free once it firesThe pinion pulled out as the pedal comes upA one-way clutch on the pinion
Pull the pinion backA springA spring
Volts to crank24Most cars: 12

So who invented the electric starter? Not Kettering alone. Coleman's patent had a motor that started the engine and then charged the battery, eight years before Kettering filed. What Kettering patented was the coupling: a pinion that goes into the flywheel only when it is needed, lined up by a slow turn; a clutch pedal that frees the car and meshes the gears in one push, but only while the button is held; and a battery rewired from six volts to twenty-four for the start (claims 6, 11, 16-23). And Cadillac put a version of it on sale for 1912 (Motor Age, 1911).

What we cannot tell you is whether Coleman's machine ever ran, or what happened on that bridge in Detroit.

Read the original patents

All four are US patents of 1903 to 1917, in the public domain. Click a page for full resolution; drawing sheets come first, then the specification. The sheets are shown as printed: several are drawn across the page.

US 745,157, Clyde J. Coleman, Means for Operating Motor-Vehicles, filed 11 February 1901, granted 24 November 1903

US 745,157, drawing sheet 1
Sheet 1: Fig. 1, the car
US 745,157, drawing sheet 2
Sheet 2: Figs. 2-4, the gearing and circuit
US 745,157, specification page 1
Page 1: "while relieved of its load"
US 745,157, specification page 2
Page 2: the two pairs of gears
US 745,157, specification page 3
Page 3: lever 24, governor 53; the claims begin
US 745,157, specification page 4
Page 4, claims
US 745,157, specification page 5
Page 5, claims
US 745,157, specification page 6
Page 6, claims; signed 8 February 1901

US 1,150,523, Charles F. Kettering, Engine-Starting Device, filed 15 June 1911, granted 17 August 1915

US 1,150,523, drawing sheet 1, drawn across the page
Sheet 1: Fig. 1, the chassis; Figs. 1a, 1b
US 1,150,523, drawing sheet 2, drawn across the page
Sheet 2: Figs. 2-5
US 1,150,523, drawing sheet 3, drawn across the page
Sheet 3: Figs. 6-8
US 1,150,523, specification page 1
Page 1: "normally disconnected"
US 1,150,523, specification page 2
Page 2
US 1,150,523, specification page 3
Page 3: "the 'Cadillac'"
US 1,150,523, specification page 4
Page 4
US 1,150,523, specification page 5
Page 5: "rotates slowly"
US 1,150,523, specification page 6
Page 6: "so quickly"
US 1,150,523, specification page 7
Page 7: "practically 24 volts"
US 1,150,523, specification page 8
Page 8: the cut-out
US 1,150,523, specification page 9
Page 9
US 1,150,523, specification page 10
Page 10
US 1,150,523, specification page 11
Page 11, claims (claim 6)
US 1,150,523, specification page 12
Page 12, claims
US 1,150,523, specification page 13
Page 13, claims
US 1,150,523, specification page 14
Page 14, claims
US 1,150,523, specification page 15
Page 15, claims

US 1,171,055, Charles F. Kettering, Engine Starting, Lighting, and Ignition System, filed 17 April 1911, granted 8 February 1916

US 1,171,055, drawing sheet 1
Sheet 1
US 1,171,055, specification page 1
Specification, page 1

US 1,231,266, Charles F. Kettering, Engine-Starting Device, divisional, filed 5 March 1915, granted 26 June 1917

US 1,231,266, drawing sheet 1
Sheet 1
US 1,231,266, specification page 1
Specification, page 1: "Divided and this application filed March 5, 1915"

Sources

Every fact on this page comes from these, as in the episode. Where we have a source only second-hand, the text says so.

Patents (US, public domain; full-page scans from the USPTO)

Period sources (public domain)

Secondary

Images